
Failed 2023 divestiture attempt now looks fortuitous as consumer dairy unit delivers $10.3M profit, 27% brand growth, and 14-16% return on capital while expanding across Southeast Asia.
Synlait Milk’s aborted attempt to sell Dairyworks during its 2023 financial crisis now appears remarkably fortunate, as the consumer dairy business has delivered extraordinary performance that would have been sacrificed in what inevitably would have been a distressed fire sale. Under previous leadership, then-CEO Grant Watson characterized Dairyworks as an excellent business with strong capabilities but not core to the company’s diversified growth strategy, prompting the engagement of Jarden to find buyers. After twelve months of soliciting interest from multiple parties without receiving a binding offer, Synlait withdrew Dairyworks and its Talbot Forest Cheese business from the market, instead pursuing a capital raise and shareholder loan to address its leverage crisis. The decision to retain the Christchurch-based Hornby operation—acquired from the Cross family for $112 million in 2020—occurred during peak financial distress when any buyer would have extracted maximum value concessions from Synlait’s weakened negotiating position.
Dairyworks’ financial trajectory under Synlait ownership demonstrates remarkable growth across all key metrics, validating the strategic decision to retain the asset despite pressure to deleverage. In its first full year within the Synlait Group ending July 2021, the cheese, butter, and yogurt operation generated $229 million revenue and just $351,000 net profit after divesting its ice cream business to Talley’s. By fiscal 2025, revenue climbed to $324.2 million while net profit surged to $10.3 million—representing nearly thirty-fold profit expansion in four years—and gross profit advanced to $39 million from $34 million the previous year. Back-of-envelope calculations suggest Dairyworks achieved return on capital between 14 and 16 percent during 2024 and 2025, performance metrics that Fonterra’s soon-to-be-formed Mainland Group could only aspire to replicate in the fiercely competitive consumer dairy marketplace.
Export market expansion has driven much of Dairyworks’ revenue growth trajectory despite weak New Zealand domestic economic conditions constraining local consumption. The business successfully entered Thai and Vietnamese markets while expanding distribution through Costco Australia and launching its Alpine brand into Australian foodservice channels, diversifying revenue streams beyond the saturated domestic market. Led by CEO Tim Carter, who reports to Synlait CEO Richard Wyeth and sits on the company’s leadership team, Dairyworks produces grated and sliced cheese, cheese-and-cracker combinations, and one-kilogram blocks under its own brand plus Rolling Meadow and Alpine labels, recently re-entering the butter category after earlier market exits. Circana Scan Data confirms Dairyworks remains among the fastest-growing brands in New Zealand’s natural cheese category, posting 27 percent dollar sales growth and 21 percent volume expansion over the trailing twelve months.
Financial analysts have taken notice of Dairyworks’ contribution to Synlait’s overall profitability profile while noting both opportunities and constraints facing the consumer business. Forsyth Barr analyst Matt Montgomerie observed in a late September note following Synlait’s full-year results that Dairyworks contributed one-quarter of the company’s total earnings before interest and tax, characterizing it as performing solidly though representing a lower structural growth business relative to other Synlait operations. Macquarie analysts highlighted Dairyworks’ uncapped growth potential given its ability to purchase, pack, and market additional volume while pursuing further export and product opportunities. However, they noted second-half EBITDA retreated below 2022 levels, likely reflecting high milk price pressures that create persistent margin compression for consumer dairy businesses unable to immediately pass input cost increases through to retail pricing.
Synlait’s leadership is finalizing future strategy during summer months as the company transitions back to pure South Island processing following completion of its long-awaited North Island transaction, with Dairyworks’ strategic role attracting significant attention amid dairy retail landscape disruption from Lactalis’ New Zealand entry. Independent director Paul McGilvary, who chairs the Dairyworks board and sought re-election at Synlait’s annual meeting, expressed confidence about profits exceeding $40 million while crediting success to relentless quality focus, efficient capital deployment, outstanding marketing capabilities, and strong management execution. McGilvary characterized Dairyworks as showing Synlait the pathway forward for value creation beyond commodity ingredients. Based on 2024 record EBITDA of $22.8 million and applying a 7.5x multiple, Dairyworks’ valuation could exceed $170 million—though some observers suggest the non-core asset could still be sold to Bega Cheese or even listed independently. However, any business multiplying net profit thirty-fold within several years represents an asset worth retaining rather than liquidating, particularly given new CEO Richard Wyeth’s background at Westland Milk Products and the arrival of sales leader Hamish Yates from the West Coast, both bringing consumer dairy expertise that positions Dairyworks for continued prominence within Synlait’s portfolio.
Source: Business analysis by BusinessDesk New Zealand – Read the complete Synlait Dairyworks performance review here
You can now read the most important #news on #eDairyNews #Whatsapp channels!!!
🇺🇸 eDairy News INGLÊS: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaKsjzGDTkJyIN6hcP1K











